Spend $50 and get FREE SHIPPING

Witch Hazel Astringent vs Toner: Which Version is Best for You?

January 4, 2023 | Keval

witch hazel toner vs astringent

Witch hazel can be a wonder product to add to your daily skincare routine. However, you may be confused by two main witch hazel products: witch hazel toner vs witch hazel astringent. If you are unsure what the differences are between these two products, you won’t have to wonder much longer. 

Continue reading through this guide where we’ll discuss the major differences between a witch hazel astringent vs toner, and how you can choose which product is right for you. 

What is Witch Hazel in the First Place?

Before we dive into the main distinctions between witch hazel toner vs witch hazel astringent, let’s first cover what witch hazel is. 

Witch hazel is a natural substance that is used topically to treat a number of different skin ailments. It comes from the witch hazel plant, where the leaves and bark are distilled down to create this product. It can be used on acne, redness, irritation, and you can even learn how to use witch hazel for hair growth, too.

For more information on witch hazel, check out our other guides on how to tell if witch hazel is expired and how long does it take for witch hazel to work so you can get the best results from this product. 

Witch Hazel Astringent vs Toner: The Different Versions Explained

With a better idea of what witch hazel is, we can now discuss how witch hazel toner and astringent differ from one another. 

What is Witch Hazel Astringent?

A witch hazel astringent is an alcohol-based solution that is a sort of strong toner. The main draw of using an astringent, then, is that it can help get rid of excess oil on the skin and that it has antibacterial properties.

Thus, people with acne-prone skin tend to like astringent because it helps prevent pore clogging and excessive oil build-up that causes breakouts. Plus, by killing bacteria on the skin, users can help prevent future breakouts from spreading or even occurring in the first place. 

Because the alcohol found in astringents can be drying, many witch hazel astringents will also include other moisturizing ingredients such as aloe for balance. 

What is Witch Hazel Toner?

On the other hand, witch hazel toner is another version of witch hazel that people commonly use in their skincare routine, though it is a little more gentle than an astringent. 

Overall, witch hazel toner is used for the purpose of tightening your skin and lessening the appearance of pores. People like using toner because it helps improve the overall appearance of their skin. Plus, it can also balance out the pH and reduce some oil build-up.

Can You Use Both Witch Hazel Astringent and Toner?

Technically, you don’t have to decide whether witch hazel toner vs witch hazel astringent is better. You can use them together without doing any harm, but it wouldn’t really make sense. This is because the two products are tailored for different skin types and skin goals. 

But before we break down the major differences between witch hazel toner vs astringent, let’s take a look at all the ways that they’re similar. 

Similarities Between Witch Hazel Toner vs Astringent

Given what the benefits are of witch hazel on skin, both the toner and astringent can be very powerful in treating pesky skin ailments. Here are all the ways that the two products have similar healing and calming effects on the skin. 

Skin Cleansing

Both witch hazel products do a good job of cleansing the skin and sloughing away harmful build-up on the surface. This includes bacteria when using an astringent, though both products do a good job of cutting through oils and revealing a smooth, pristine surface after use.

Inflammation Control

Additionally, the tannins that are naturally found in witch hazel, and thus both products have calming properties that bring down inflammation in the skin. This can also help reduce the appearance of redness, which you can get from both a toner and an astringent. 

Skin Tightening Sensation

Another area where the two products are similar is with the skin tightening that they provide to users. This helps shrink the appearance of pores, reduces blackheads, and leaves people feeling fresh and brighter. 

Witch Hazel Astringent vs Toner: Which is Better?

Now that you know how witch hazel toner vs astringent are similar, let’s discuss the times when they’re each more effective than the other. 

Understanding Your Skin Type

The first thing you should consider when choosing between these two witch hazel products is the type of skin you have. 

If you’re someone with very oily skin and always have a constant shine, an astringent is a good match for you. On the other hand, someone with more sensitive or dry skin naturally would be better of using the toner. 

People with combination skin may show a preference for one over the other, but this might take some trial and error to see what feels best.

Effects/Results Produced

You may also want to assess what you’re trying to achieve with the witch hazel product. If you’re trying to cut down on the oil build-up on your face and really cleanse out your pores, you’ll bet the best results from an astringent. 

Those who want to cut down on inflammation and redness, but get a more moisturized feel after using witch hazel, will like using a toner better. 

So just as you should pay attention to the type of skin you have when choosing between these products, you should also consider the effects you want as well. 

So, Which is Better Astringent or Toner?

After reading through this guide, you may be wondering at this point if witch hazel toner or witch hazel astringent is a better product. 

Considering everything we’ve discussed so far, we’d like to reiterate that there is no clear winner between the two, as they both accomplish very important results for different people and scenarios. 

So while an astringent could be really beneficial for one person, someone else using the same product might find that it’s too harsh for everyday use. Thus, each person will have their own preference and experience with these two products, so you’ll need to use the one that’s best for you and your skin. 

Quick Tips for Using Either Witch Hazel Astringent or Toner

After reading through the different cases that might make one of these products better for you than the other, we want to provide you with some additional tips and suggestions so you can get the most out of either witch hazel product. 

Consistent Use

To get the best results from using witch hazel on your face, you should be using it consistently. This will help keep your pores clear, oil levels down, and redness and inflammation at bay. If you only use it one or two times a week, you may not get the intended results. 

However, many people ask does witch hazel burn when applied–and the answer is that when using good products correctly, it shouldn’t. So, pay attention if you start to feel your skin burning after applying witch hazel. In this case, you may want to back off a little bit and only use it every other day to not overstrip your skin and cause more harm than good. 

Use the Best Products

In order to see the best results from both witch hazel toner and astringent, you need to discover the best witch hazel to buy. This is possibly the most important step to getting the most out of witch hazel’s wonderful properties, so don’t overlook this or skimp out on buying quality products. 

For the best witch hazel around, you need to check out our selection here at Somebody. We have a fantastic witch hazel spray made with a centuries-old formulation that’s been used to treat wounds, inflammation, and other skin ailments for years. 

What is witch hazel spray? It’s simply a quality witch hazel solution placed in a convenient spray bottle that can easily be applied all over your body. Our spray comes in three amazing scents as well for a boost of aromatherapy with your witch hazel. 

Wrapping Up Our Comparison Guide on Witch Hazel Astringent vs Witch Hazel Toner

Both witch hazel astringent and toner can be amazing additions to your skincare routine, though you need to make the proper considerations to see which one is the right fit for you. 

At Somebody, we have amazing witch hazel products for any skin type and ailments you might have, but we also have many other amazing wellness products to help you look and feel your best. 

Check out our CBD products like our CBD headache roller, CBD joint & muscle balm, and CBD transdermal patch that can treat aches and pains wherever they are on the body. So if you want to overhaul your self-care routine in the new year, you need to visit Somebody and get your hands on some of our amazing products today. 

Your Cart
Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
Calculate Shipping
Apply Coupon
If you won a coupon code, it will be applied automatically during checkout or you can enter your code above for eligible promotions. Multiple coupons cannot be used. Minimum $30 order required.